If any of my solutions look wrong, please refer to the mark scheme. You can exit full-screen mode for the question paper and mark scheme by clicking the icon in the bottom-right corner or by pressing Esc on your keyboard.

Interactive Exam: GCSE November 2017 Edexcel Higher Paper 1

Edexcel GCSE Mathematics – November 2017

Higher Tier – Paper 1 (Non-Calculator)

Mark Scheme Legend

  • (M1) – Method mark: awarded for a correct method or partial method.
  • (P1) – Process mark: awarded for a correct process as part of a problem-solving question.
  • (A1) – Accuracy mark: awarded after a correct method or process.
  • (B1) – Unconditional accuracy mark: no method needed.
  • (C1) – Communication mark: awarded for clear reasoning or justification.

Question 1 (2 marks)

Write \(36\) as a product of its prime factors.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Understanding Prime Factors

What are we being asked to find?

We need to break down the number \(36\) into numbers that multiply together to make it, where every number must be a prime number (like \(2, 3, 5, 7, 11\), etc.).

Step 2: Breaking down the number (Factor Tree Method)

Why we do this:

We can systematically divide \(36\) by the smallest prime numbers first. Let’s start by dividing by \(2\) because \(36\) is an even number.

Working:

\[ \begin{aligned} 36 &= 2 \times 18 \\ 18 &= 2 \times 9 \\ 9 &= 3 \times 3 \end{aligned} \]

So gathering all our prime ends:

\[ 36 = 2 \times 2 \times 3 \times 3 \]

(M1) for a complete method to find prime factors (e.g., a factor tree) with no more than 1 arithmetic error.

What this tells us:

Our prime factors are \(2, 2, 3,\) and \(3\). We can check our answer by multiplying them back together: \(2 \times 2 = 4\), \(3 \times 3 = 9\), and \(4 \times 9 = 36\). Perfect!

Final Answer:

\(2 \times 2 \times 3 \times 3\) (or \(2^2 \times 3^2\))

(A1) correct answer only.

Total: 2 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 2 (4 marks)

Kiaria is \(7\) years older than Jay.

Martha is twice as old as Kiaria.

The sum of their three ages is \(77\).

Find the ratio of Jay’s age to Kiaria’s age to Martha’s age.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Setting up algebraic expressions

What are we being asked to find?

We need to find the specific age of each person and then write them as a ratio. To do this, let’s turn the English sentences into algebra.

Why we do this:

Letting the youngest person’s age be a letter (like \(x\)) makes it easiest to construct the other ages without using fractions or subtraction.

Working:

Let Jay’s age = \(x\)

Kiaria is 7 years older: Kiaria’s age = \(x + 7\)

Martha is twice as old as Kiaria: Martha’s age = \(2(x + 7)\)

Expanding Martha’s age: \(2x + 14\)

(P1) for writing at least 2 out of 3 expressions correctly in one letter.

Step 2: Forming and solving the equation

Why we do this:

We are told the sum of all three ages is \(77\). We can add our three algebraic expressions together and set them equal to \(77\).

Working:

\[ \text{Jay} + \text{Kiaria} + \text{Martha} = 77 \] \[ x + (x + 7) + (2x + 14) = 77 \]

(P1) for the sum of their 3 expressions = 77.

Combine the \(x\) terms and the numbers:

\[ 4x + 21 = 77 \]

Subtract \(21\) from both sides. Let’s do a quick mental or column subtraction: \(77 – 20 = 57\), minus \(1\) is \(56\).

\[ 4x = 56 \]

Divide by \(4\) to isolate \(x\):

\[ x = \frac{56}{4} = 14 \]

(P1) for a correct process to isolate the term in \(x\) (finding \(x=14\)).

Step 3: Calculating individual ages and writing the ratio

Why we do this:

Now that we know Jay’s age (\(x = 14\)), we can substitute this back into our expressions to find the other two ages, and finally write our answer in the requested ratio format (Jay : Kiaria : Martha).

Working:

  • Jay = \(14\)
  • Kiaria = \(14 + 7 = 21\)
  • Martha = \(2 \times 21 = 42\)

Let’s check the sum: \(14 + 21 + 42 = 35 + 42 = 77\). This matches!

Ratio: Jay : Kiaria : Martha

\[ 14 : 21 : 42 \]

Final Answer:

\(14 : 21 : 42\)

(A1) for the correct ratio.

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 3 (4 marks)

\(ABCD\) is a parallelogram.

\(EDC\) is a straight line.

\(F\) is the point on \(AD\) so that \(BFE\) is a straight line.

Angle \(EFD = 35^\circ\)

Angle \(DCB = 75^\circ\)

Show that angle \(ABF = 70^\circ\).

Give a reason for each stage of your working.

75° 35° A B C D E F

Worked Solution

Step 1: Identifying opposite angles in a parallelogram

What are we doing first?

We need to find the measure of angle \(\angle ABF\). To get there, we can use the properties of parallelograms to find the inner angles.

Why we do this:

In a parallelogram, opposite angles are equal. Since we are given \(\angle DCB = 75^\circ\), we know the opposite angle at vertex A must also be \(75^\circ\).

Working:

\[ \angle FAB = 75^\circ \]

Reason: Opposite angles in a parallelogram are equal.

(B1) for identifying an angle of \(75^\circ\) or \(35^\circ\) correctly.

Step 2: Finding a vertically opposite angle

Why we do this:

Look at the lines crossing at point F (line AD and line BE). When two straight lines intersect, the angles opposite each other are equal. This will give us another angle inside triangle \(ABF\).

Working:

\[ \angle AFB = \angle EFD = 35^\circ \]

Reason: Vertically opposite angles are equal.

(M1) for a correct pair of angles that lead to solving the triangle.

Step 3: Calculating the final angle in the triangle

Why we do this:

Now we have two of the three angles inside triangle \(ABF\). We know \(\angle FAB = 75^\circ\) and \(\angle AFB = 35^\circ\). Since angles in a triangle always add up to \(180^\circ\), we can subtract the known angles from 180 to find \(\angle ABF\).

Working:

\[ \text{Sum of known angles} = 75^\circ + 35^\circ = 110^\circ \] \[ \angle ABF = 180^\circ – 110^\circ = 70^\circ \]

Reason: Angles in a triangle sum to \(180^\circ\).

(C2) for a full solution with all appropriate reasons stated clearly.

What this tells us:

We have successfully shown that \(\angle ABF = 70^\circ\) using geometric rules, exactly as the question asked us to show.

Final Answer:

Shown: \(\angle ABF = 70^\circ\) with reasons:
1. Opposite angles in a parallelogram are equal.
2. Vertically opposite angles are equal.
3. Angles in a triangle sum to \(180^\circ\).

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 4 (4 marks)

The diagram shows a logo made from three circles.

Each circle has centre \(O\).

Daisy says that exactly \(\frac{1}{3}\) of the logo is shaded.

Is Daisy correct? You must show all your working.

O 4 cm 3 cm 3 cm

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding the radii of the three circles

What are we being asked to find?

To check if Daisy is correct, we need to compare the shaded area to the total area of the logo. First, we need the exact radius of each circle.

Working:

Radius of inner white circle = \(4\text{ cm}\)

Radius of middle (shaded edge) circle = \(4 + 3 = 7\text{ cm}\)

Radius of outer circle (whole logo) = \(7 + 3 = 10\text{ cm}\)

Step 2: Calculating the areas of the circles

Why we do this:

The area of any circle is \(\pi \times r^2\). We need the area of the whole logo, and the areas of the inner and middle circles to figure out just the shaded ring.

Working:

Area of whole logo (outer circle) = \(\pi \times 10^2 = 100\pi\)

Area of middle circle = \(\pi \times 7^2 = 49\pi\)

Area of inner circle = \(\pi \times 4^2 = 16\pi\)

(P1) for finding the area of any relevant circle in terms of \(\pi\) (or calculating \(7^2\) and \(4^2\)).

Step 3: Calculating the shaded area

Why we do this:

The shaded part is a “ring” (an annulus). We find its area by taking the area of the middle circle and subtracting the empty inner circle that is cut out of it.

Working:

\[ \text{Shaded Area} = \text{Area of middle circle} – \text{Area of inner circle} \] \[ \text{Shaded Area} = 49\pi – 16\pi = 33\pi \]

(P1) for a complete method to find the shaded area.

Step 4: Comparing fractions

Why we do this:

We need to see if the shaded fraction is exactly \(\frac{1}{3}\). We take our shaded area and divide it by the total area.

Working:

\[ \text{Fraction shaded} = \frac{33\pi}{100\pi} \]

The \(\pi\) symbols cancel out, leaving us with:

\[ \text{Fraction shaded} = \frac{33}{100} \]

(A1) for reaching the two comparable figures (e.g., \(33\) and \(100\)).

Daisy thinks it is \(\frac{1}{3}\). But \(\frac{1}{3} = \frac{33.333…}{100}\).

\(\frac{33}{100}\) is close, but it is not exactly \(\frac{1}{3}\).

(C1) for a clear concluding statement.

Final Answer:

No, Daisy is incorrect. The exact shaded fraction is \(\frac{33}{100}\), not \(\frac{1}{3}\).

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 5 (4 marks)

The table shows information about the weekly earnings of \(20\) people who work in a shop.

Weekly earnings (£\(x\)) Frequency
\(150 < x \le 250\) \(1\)
\(250 < x \le 350\) \(11\)
\(350 < x \le 450\) \(5\)
\(450 < x \le 550\) \(0\)
\(550 < x \le 650\) \(3\)

(a) Work out an estimate for the mean of the weekly earnings. (3 marks)

Nadiya says, “The mean may not be the best average to use to represent this information.”

(b) Do you agree with Nadiya? You must justify your answer. (1 mark)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Part (a) – Finding midpoints to estimate the mean

What are we doing?

Because the earnings are grouped into ranges (classes), we don’t know exactly what each person earns. To estimate, we assume everyone in a group earns exactly the middle value of that group. This middle value is called the midpoint.

Working:

Midpoint of \(150\) to \(250\) = \((150 + 250) \div 2 = 200\)

Midpoint of \(250\) to \(350\) = \(300\)

Midpoint of \(350\) to \(450\) = \(400\)

Midpoint of \(450\) to \(550\) = \(500\)

Midpoint of \(550\) to \(650\) = \(600\)

Step 2: Multiplying midpoints by frequency

Why we do this:

If we assume \(11\) people earn exactly £\(300\), the total earned by that group is \(11 \times 300\). We must multiply each midpoint by its frequency, then add them all up to find the total estimated earnings for all 20 people.

Working:

  • \(200 \times 1 = 200\)
  • \(300 \times 11 = 3300\)
  • \(400 \times 5 = 2000\)
  • \(500 \times 0 = 0\)
  • \(600 \times 3 = 1800\)

(M1) for calculating products of frequency \(\times\) midpoint (allowing 1 error).

Total estimated earnings: \(200 + 3300 + 2000 + 0 + 1800\)

  200
 3300
 2000
    0
+1800
-----
 7300
 1
-----
Step 3: Calculating the final mean

Why we do this:

The mean is the total amount divided by the total number of people (\(20\)).

Working:

\[ \text{Mean} = \frac{7300}{20} \]

(M1) for dividing the sum of their products by 20.

Cancel a zero: \(\frac{730}{2}\).

Half of \(730\) is \(365\).

(A1) for arriving at 365.

Step 4: Part (b) – Justifying Nadiya’s statement

Why we do this:

We need to look at our data distribution. Most people (\(11 + 5 = 16\) people) earn between £250 and £450. But \(3\) people earn very high amounts (£550-£650). These extreme high values are called “outliers” and they drag the mean upwards, making it seem like the “average” worker earns more than they really do.

Working:

Yes, I agree with Nadiya. The \(3\) high earners in the £550-£650 group are extreme values (outliers) that pull the mean artificially high. The median would be a better representation of the typical worker’s pay.

(C1) for a valid comment about outliers or skewness affecting the mean.

Final Answer:

(a) £\(365\)

(b) Yes, because there are extreme values (outliers) at the top end (£550-£650) which skew the mean upwards.

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 6 (4 marks)

Here is a rectangle.

y 2x + 6 5x − 9

All measurements are in centimetres.

The area of the rectangle is \(48\text{ cm}^2\).

Show that \(y = 3\).

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding \(x\) using the properties of a rectangle

What are we being asked to find?

We need to prove that the top side (\(y\)) has a length of \(3\text{ cm}\). To get there, we first need to figure out what the side lengths actually are by finding \(x\).

Why we do this:

We know that opposite sides of a rectangle are exactly the same length. This means the left side (\(2x + 6\)) must be equal to the right side (\(5x – 9\)). We can turn this into an equation to find \(x\).

Working:

\[ 5x – 9 = 2x + 6 \]

(M1) for forming this equation.

Subtract \(2x\) from both sides to get the \(x\)’s on one side:

\[ 3x – 9 = 6 \]

Add \(9\) to both sides:

\[ 3x = 15 \]

Divide by \(3\):

\[ x = 5 \]

(M1) for isolating \(x\) and number terms correctly.

Step 2: Calculating the length of the side

Why we do this:

Now that we know \(x = 5\), we can substitute it back into either expression to find the actual physical length of the side of the rectangle.

Working:

Using the left side: Length \(= 2(5) + 6 = 10 + 6 = 16\text{ cm}\)

Let’s check with the right side just to be sure: Length \(= 5(5) – 9 = 25 – 9 = 16\text{ cm}\). It matches!

Step 3: Using the area to find \(y\)

Why we do this:

We are told the area is \(48\text{ cm}^2\). The formula for the area of a rectangle is \(\text{base} \times \text{height}\) (or \(\text{width} \times \text{length}\)). We know the height is \(16\text{ cm}\), and the width is \(y\).

Working:

\[ \text{Area} = 16 \times y \] \[ 48 = 16y \]

(M1) for forming the second equation using the area.

Divide by \(16\) to find \(y\):

\[ y = \frac{48}{16} \]

Since \(16 \times 2 = 32\), and \(16 \times 3 = 48\):

\[ y = 3 \]

(A1) for completing the correct reasoning to reach \(y = 3\).

What this tells us:

We successfully worked backwards from the properties of the rectangle and its area to prove that the top side \(y\) must be \(3\text{ cm}\).

Final Answer:

Shown correctly: \(y = 3\)

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 7 (1 mark)

Brogan needs to draw the graph of \(y = x^2 + 1\)

Here is her graph.

x y O -4 -3 -2 -1 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 y = x2 + 1

Write down one thing that is wrong with Brogan’s graph.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Understanding quadratic graphs

What are we looking for?

The equation given is \(y = x^2 + 1\). Any equation with an \(x^2\) term (and no higher powers) is called a quadratic equation. Quadratic equations always produce a smooth, “U”-shaped curve called a parabola.

Step 2: Finding the error in Brogan’s graph

What did she do wrong?

If you look closely at how the points (the crosses) are connected, you can see sharp corners. Brogan has used a ruler to draw straight lines between each point, rather than drawing a continuous, smooth curve freehand.

Because quadratic graphs are always smooth curves, joining the points with straight line segments makes the graph mathematically incorrect.

(B1) for a correct mathematical comment indicating the points should not be connected with straight lines.

Final Answer:

The points should be joined with a smooth freehand curve, not with straight line segments using a ruler.

Total: 1 mark

↑ Back to Top

Question 8 (2 marks)

Write these numbers in order of size. Start with the smallest number.

\(0.246\)

\(0.2\dot{4}\dot{6}\)

\(0.\dot{2}4\dot{6}\)

\(0.24\dot{6}\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Understanding recurring decimal notation

What are we being asked to do?

We need to order four decimal numbers. Three of them have dots above some digits. A dot means that digit (and any digits between dots) repeats forever. To compare them, the easiest method is to expand them out to a few decimal places so we can look at them side-by-side.

Step 2: Expanding the decimals

Why we do this:

It’s hard to compare recurring decimals just by looking at the dots. If we write out the first 5 or 6 decimal places, it becomes very easy to see which is largest.

Working:

  • \(0.246 = 0.246000…\) (no dots, so it ends with zeros)
  • \(0.2\dot{4}\dot{6} = 0.2464646…\) (the 4 and 6 repeat)
  • \(0.\dot{2}4\dot{6} = 0.246246…\) (the 2, 4, and 6 repeat)
  • \(0.24\dot{6} = 0.246666…\) (only the 6 repeats)

(M1) for correct expansion of the recurring symbol (e.g., \(0.2\dot{4}\dot{6} = 0.24646…\)).

Step 3: Comparing the columns

Why we do this:

Just like putting words in alphabetical order, we look at the numbers column by column from left to right. The first time a column is different, the smallest number in that column belongs to the smallest overall number.

Working:

Looking at the 4th decimal place (since the first three are all \(246\)):

  • \(0.246\mathbf{0}00…\) (0 is smallest) -> 1st
  • \(0.246\mathbf{2}46…\) (2 is next) -> 2nd
  • \(0.246\mathbf{4}64…\) (4 is next) -> 3rd
  • \(0.246\mathbf{6}66…\) (6 is largest) -> 4th

What this tells us:

Now we just need to write them down in this order using their original printed formats.

Final Answer:

\(0.246\), \(0.\dot{2}4\dot{6}\), \(0.2\dot{4}\dot{6}\), \(0.24\dot{6}\)

(A1) for the correct order.

Total: 2 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 9 (5 marks)

James and Peter cycled along the same \(50\text{ km}\) route.

James took \(2\frac{1}{2}\) hours to cycle the \(50\text{ km}\).

Peter started to cycle \(5\) minutes after James started to cycle.

Peter caught up with James when they had both cycled \(15\text{ km}\).

James and Peter both cycled at constant speeds.

Work out Peter’s speed.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding James’s constant speed

What are we being asked to find?

We eventually need Peter’s speed. To find speed, we need Distance and Time. We know Peter cycled \(15\text{ km}\) to catch up, but we don’t know his time yet. Let’s start by figuring out everything we can about James.

Why we do this:

We know James’s total distance (\(50\text{ km}\)) and total time (\(2.5\) hours). We can use the formula \(\text{Speed} = \text{Distance} \div \text{Time}\) to find his speed.

Working:

\[ \text{James’s Speed} = 50 \div 2.5 \]

To divide by a decimal, we can multiply both numbers by \(10\):

\[ 500 \div 25 = 20\text{ km/h} \]

(P1) for process to find James’s speed.

Step 2: Finding James’s time to reach the 15km mark

Why we do this:

Peter catches James at the \(15\text{ km}\) mark. If we know how long James had been cycling to get to that point, we can figure out Peter’s time.

Working:

Using the formula \(\text{Time} = \text{Distance} \div \text{Speed}\):

\[ \text{Time taken by James} = 15 \div 20 \]

This fraction simplifies to \(\frac{3}{4}\) of an hour.

\(\frac{3}{4}\) of an hour is \(45\) minutes.

(P1) for process to find James’s time for 15 km.

Step 3: Finding Peter’s time to the 15km mark

Why we do this:

Peter caught up to James exactly when James had been cycling for \(45\) minutes. However, Peter started \(5\) minutes after James. This means Peter wasn’t cycling for the full \(45\) minutes.

Working:

\[ \text{Peter’s Time} = 45\text{ mins} – 5\text{ mins} = 40\text{ minutes} \]

(P1) for process to find Peter’s time for 15 km.

Step 4: Calculating Peter’s speed

Why we do this:

Now we have Peter’s distance (\(15\text{ km}\)) and his time (\(40\) minutes). The final answer needs to be in km/h, so we must first convert his \(40\) minutes into hours before dividing.

Working:

\(40\) minutes out of \(60\) is \(\frac{40}{60}\) hours, which simplifies to \(\frac{2}{3}\) hours.

\[ \text{Peter’s Speed} = \text{Distance} \div \text{Time} \] \[ \text{Peter’s Speed} = 15 \div \frac{2}{3} \]

(P1) for correct process to find Peter’s speed.

To divide by a fraction, we multiply by the reciprocal (flip the second fraction):

\[ 15 \times \frac{3}{2} = \frac{45}{2} = 22.5\text{ km/h} \]

Final Answer:

\(22.5\text{ km/h}\)

(A1) for the correct answer.

Total: 5 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 10 (3 marks)

(a) Write down the value of \(100^{\frac{1}{2}}\)

(b) Find the value of \(125^{\frac{2}{3}}\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Part (a) – Dealing with the power of 1/2

What are we doing?

A fractional power of \(\frac{1}{2}\) is exactly the same as finding the square root of the number.

Working:

\[ 100^{\frac{1}{2}} = \sqrt{100} = 10 \]

(B1) for correct value (accept \(\pm10\)).

Step 2: Part (b) – Dealing with the power of 2/3

Why we do this:

For a fractional power like \(\frac{2}{3}\), the fraction tells you two separate operations to perform on the number. The denominator (bottom) is the root, and the numerator (top) is the power.

  • The \(3\) on the bottom means we take the cube root.
  • The \(2\) on top means we then square the result.

It is always easier to do the root first so the numbers stay small.

Working:

First, find the cube root of \(125\). What number multiplied by itself three times gives \(125\)?

\[ \sqrt[3]{125} = 5 \]

(M1) for finding \(\sqrt[3]{125} = 5\) or showing \((\sqrt[3]{125})^2\).

Next, we apply the squared power to our result:

\[ 5^2 = 5 \times 5 = 25 \]

Final Answer:

(a) \(10\)

(b) \(25\)

(A1) for 25.

Total: 3 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 11 (4 marks)

\(3\) teas and \(2\) coffees have a total cost of £\(7.80\)

\(5\) teas and \(4\) coffees have a total cost of £\(14.20\)

Work out the cost of one tea and the cost of one coffee.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Setting up simultaneous equations

What are we being asked to find?

We need to find two unknown prices (cost of a tea, cost of a coffee). Because we have two unknowns and two different scenarios, we can write this as a pair of simultaneous equations.

Why we do this:

Let’s use letters to represent the unknown costs: let \(t\) be the cost of one tea, and \(c\) be the cost of one coffee. We can translate the English sentences directly into algebra.

Working:

Equation 1: \(3t + 2c = 7.80\)

Equation 2: \(5t + 4c = 14.20\)

(P1) for setting up two appropriate equations.

Step 2: Eliminating one of the variables

Why we do this:

To solve for one variable, we need to eliminate the other. If we look at the coffees, we have \(2c\) in the first equation and \(4c\) in the second. If we multiply the entire first equation by \(2\), both equations will have \(4c\). Then we can subtract one equation from the other to make the \(c\) terms disappear.

Working:

Multiply Equation 1 by \(2\):

\[ 2 \times (3t + 2c = 7.80) \] \[ 6t + 4c = 15.60 \quad \text{(Equation 3)} \]

Now, subtract Equation 2 from Equation 3:

  6t + 4c = 15.60
-(5t + 4c = 14.20)
------------------
  1t + 0c =  1.40
\[ t = 1.40 \]

(M1) for a correct method to eliminate one variable.

Step 3: Finding the second variable

Why we do this:

Now that we know the cost of a tea (\(t = 1.40\)), we can substitute this value back into either of the original equations to find the cost of a coffee (\(c\)).

Working:

Substitute \(t = 1.40\) into Equation 1:

\[ 3(1.40) + 2c = 7.80 \]

\(3 \times 1.40 = 4.20\), so:

\[ 4.20 + 2c = 7.80 \]

Subtract \(4.20\) from both sides:

\[ 2c = 7.80 – 4.20 \] \[ 2c = 3.60 \]

Divide by \(2\):

\[ c = 1.80 \]

(M1) for a correct method to substitute the found variable to find the second.

Final Answer:

Tea: £\(1.40\)

Coffee: £\(1.80\)

(A1) for both correct amounts with correct money notation.

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 12 (5 marks)

The table shows information about the heights, in cm, of a group of Year 11 girls.

least height \(154\)
median \(165\)
lower quartile \(161\)
interquartile range \(7\)
range \(20\)

(a) Draw a box plot for this information.

Year 11

130 140 150 160 170 180 height (cm)

The box plot below shows information about the heights, in cm, of a group of Year 7 girls.

Year 7

130 140 150 160 170 180 height (cm)

(b) Compare the distribution of heights of the Year 7 girls with the distribution of heights of the Year 11 girls.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Part (a) – Calculating missing Box Plot values

What are we doing?

To draw a box plot, we need 5 key values: the minimum, the lower quartile (LQ), the median, the upper quartile (UQ), and the maximum. We have three of these, but we need to calculate the UQ and the maximum using the range and interquartile range (IQR).

Why we do this:

The IQR is the difference between the Upper Quartile and Lower Quartile (\(UQ – LQ = IQR\)). The Range is the difference between the maximum and minimum (\(\text{Max} – \text{Min} = \text{Range}\)).

Working:

Find the Upper Quartile (UQ):

\[ \text{UQ} = \text{LQ} + \text{IQR} = 161 + 7 = 168\text{ cm} \]

Find the Maximum value (Highest height):

\[ \text{Max} = \text{Least height} + \text{Range} = 154 + 20 = 174\text{ cm} \]

(M1) for method to find UQ (\(168\)) or highest value (\(174\)).

Step 2: Drawing the Year 11 Box Plot

How we draw it:

We plot vertical lines for our 5 values: \(154\) (min), \(161\) (LQ), \(165\) (median), \(168\) (UQ), and \(174\) (max). We draw a box from the LQ to the UQ, and whiskers out to the min and max.

130 140 150 160 170 180 height (cm)

(M1) for showing a box and at least 3 correctly plotted values.

(A1) for a fully correct box plot.

Step 3: Part (b) – Comparing the distributions

What are we comparing?

When asked to compare distributions, we MUST make two specific comparisons in context:

  1. Compare an average (the Median). This tells us who is generally taller.
  2. Compare the spread (the IQR or Range). This tells us which group’s heights are more consistent/varied.

Working:

From the Year 7 box plot we can read:

  • Year 7 Median = \(157.5\text{ cm}\)
  • Year 7 IQR = \(164.5 – 154 = 10.5\text{ cm}\)

From our Year 11 data:

  • Year 11 Median = \(165\text{ cm}\)
  • Year 11 IQR = \(7\text{ cm}\)

Comparison 1 (Median): The median height for Year 11 (\(165\text{ cm}\)) is higher than the median height for Year 7 (\(157.5\text{ cm}\)). This means the Year 11 girls are generally taller on average.

(C1) for comparing the median in context.

Comparison 2 (Spread): The interquartile range for Year 11 (\(7\text{ cm}\)) is smaller than the interquartile range for Year 7 (\(10.5\text{ cm}\)). This means the heights of the Year 11 girls are less spread out (more consistent) than the Year 7 girls.

(C1) for comparing the spread in context.

Final Answer:

(a) See box plot diagram above.

(b) 1. On average, the Year 11 girls are taller because their median height (\(165\text{ cm}\)) is greater than the Year 7 median (\(157.5\text{ cm}\)).

2. The heights of the Year 11 girls are more consistent (less spread out) because their Interquartile Range (\(7\text{ cm}\)) is smaller than the Year 7 Interquartile Range (\(10.5\text{ cm}\)).

Total: 5 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 13 (4 marks)

A factory makes \(450\) pies every day.

The pies are chicken pies or steak pies.

Each day Milo takes a sample of \(15\) pies to check.

The proportion of the pies in his sample that are chicken is the same as the proportion of the pies made that day that are chicken.

(a) On Monday Milo calculated that he needed exactly \(4\) chicken pies in his sample. Work out the total number of chicken pies that were made on Monday. (2 marks)

On Tuesday, the number of steak pies Milo needs in his sample is \(6\) correct to the nearest whole number.

Milo takes at random a pie from the \(450\) pies made on Tuesday.

(b) Work out the lower bound of the probability that the pie is a steak pie. (2 marks)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Part (a) – Finding total chicken pies

What are we doing?

We know that the ratio of chicken pies in the small sample (\(15\) pies) is exactly the same as the ratio of chicken pies in the whole daily batch (\(450\) pies).

Why we do this:

We can set up equivalent fractions: \(\frac{\text{chicken in sample}}{\text{total in sample}} = \frac{\text{total chicken made}}{\text{total made}}\).

Working:

\[ \frac{4}{15} = \frac{x}{450} \]

(P1) for setting up the proportion.

To solve for \(x\), multiply both sides by \(450\):

\[ x = \frac{4 \times 450}{15} \]

It’s easier to divide \(450\) by \(15\) first. We know \(15 \times 3 = 45\), so \(15 \times 30 = 450\).

\[ x = 4 \times 30 = 120 \]

(A1) for getting 120.

Step 2: Part (b) – Finding bounds for Tuesday’s sample

Why we do this:

On Tuesday, the number of steak pies in the sample was rounded to \(6\). We need the lower bound of this number to find the minimum possible probability. A number that rounds to \(6\) to the nearest whole number could be anything from \(5.5\) up to just below \(6.5\).

Working:

Lower bound for number of steak pies in the sample = \(5.5\)

This means the smallest possible proportion of steak pies in the sample is \(\frac{5.5}{15}\).

Step 3: Calculating the total lower bound and probability

Why we do this:

Because the proportion in the sample is identical to the whole factory floor, the probability of picking a steak pie from the whole batch is identical to the proportion in the sample.

However, probability is usually not written with decimals inside fractions. We need to scale it up to the total factory numbers (\(450\)).

Working:

Lower bound of total steak pies made = \(\frac{5.5}{15} \times 450\)

(P1) for identifying 5.5 and multiplying to scale up.

As we saw earlier, \(450 \div 15 = 30\). So:

\[ 5.5 \times 30 = 165 \]

So the minimum possible number of steak pies made is \(165\).

The probability of picking one from the total is therefore:

\[ \frac{165}{450} \]

(A1) for the correct probability fraction.

Final Answer:

(a) \(120\) chicken pies

(b) \(\frac{165}{450}\) (or simplified to \(\frac{11}{30}\))

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 14 (3 marks)

The ratio \((y + x) : (y – x)\) is equivalent to \(k : 1\)

Show that \(y = \frac{x(k + 1)}{k – 1}\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Writing the ratio as an equation

What are we being asked to do?

We need to rearrange a ratio statement into a specific algebraic formula where \(y\) is the subject (on its own on one side).

Why we do this:

A ratio \(A : B = C : D\) can be written as fractions: \(\frac{A}{B} = \frac{C}{D}\). This makes it much easier to do algebra.

Working:

\[ \frac{y + x}{y – x} = \frac{k}{1} \]

Since anything divided by 1 is just itself, this is:

\[ \frac{y + x}{y – x} = k \]

(M1) for correctly setting up the fraction equation.

Step 2: Getting rid of the fraction and expanding

Why we do this:

We have \(y\) stuck on both the top and bottom of a fraction. To fix this, we multiply both sides of the equation by the denominator \((y – x)\) to clear the fraction, and then expand the brackets.

Working:

\[ y + x = k(y – x) \]

Expand the bracket on the right:

\[ y + x = ky – kx \]
Step 3: Collecting the \(y\) terms together

Why we do this:

Because we want the final equation to say “\(y = …\)”, we need all terms with a \(y\) in them on one side, and everything else on the other side.

Working:

Let’s move the \(y\) from the left over to the right (by subtracting \(y\)), and move the \(-kx\) from the right over to the left (by adding \(kx\)).

\[ x + kx = ky – y \]

(M1) for isolating \(x\) and \(y\) on opposite sides.

Step 4: Factorising to isolate \(y\)

Why we do this:

We have \(ky – y\). To get a single \(y\), we factorise it out. We do the same for the \(x\) on the other side so it matches the format we’ve been asked to show.

Working:

Factorise \(x\) out of the left side:

\[ x(1 + k) \]

Factorise \(y\) out of the right side:

\[ y(k – 1) \]

So we have:

\[ x(k + 1) = y(k – 1) \]

Now, divide both sides by \((k – 1)\) to get \(y\) completely by itself:

\[ \frac{x(k + 1)}{k – 1} = y \]

(A1) for completing correct algebraic reasoning to reach the conclusion.

Final Answer:

Shown correctly: \(y = \frac{x(k + 1)}{k – 1}\)

Total: 3 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 15 (3 marks)

\(x = 0.4\dot{3}\dot{6}\)

Prove algebraically that \(x\) can be written as \(\frac{24}{55}\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Setting up equations to align the repeating parts

What are we doing?

We want to convert a repeating decimal into a fraction. The trick is to create two equations where the infinitely repeating tail (the \(3636…\) part) perfectly lines up after the decimal point, so we can subtract them and make the infinite part vanish.

Working:

Let \(x = 0.4363636…\)

Multiply by \(10\) to get the decimal point right before the repeating sequence begins:

\[ 10x = 4.363636… \quad \text{(Equation 1)} \]

Now, we want another equation with the exact same tail. The repeating sequence is two digits long (3 and 6). So we multiply our new equation by \(100\):

\[ 10x \times 100 = 1000x \] \[ 1000x = 436.3636… \quad \text{(Equation 2)} \]

(M1) for correctly finding \(1000x\) and \(10x\) (or \(100x\) and \(x\) depending on method).

Step 2: Subtracting the equations

Why we do this:

By subtracting Equation 1 from Equation 2, the infinitely repeating “.3636…” tails cancel each other out completely, leaving us with a simple whole number equation.

Working:

 1000x = 436.363636...
-  10x =   4.363636...
----------------------
  990x = 432.000000...
\[ 990x = 432 \]

(M1) for finding a difference that leads to a terminating decimal/whole number.

Step 3: Simplifying the fraction

Why we do this:

We divide by \(990\) to find \(x\) as a fraction. Then we simplify it down until we reach the target fraction of \(\frac{24}{55}\).

Working:

\[ x = \frac{432}{990} \]

Both end in an even number or zero, so let’s halve them:

\[ x = \frac{216}{495} \]

Check if they divide by \(9\) (sum of digits rule: \(2+1+6=9\) and \(4+9+5=18\), so yes they do!).

For the numerator: \(216 \div 9\). Let’s use a quick bus stop or mental math (\(9 \times 20 = 180\), leaving \(36\). \(9 \times 4 = 36\). So \(24\)).

For the denominator: \(495 \div 9\). (\(9 \times 50 = 450\), leaving \(45\). \(9 \times 5 = 45\). So \(55\)).

\[ x = \frac{24}{55} \]

(A1) for successfully completing the algebra to reach \(\frac{24}{55}\).

Final Answer:

Proven algebraically: \(x = \frac{24}{55}\)

Total: 3 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 16 (3 marks)

\(y\) is directly proportional to \(\sqrt[3]{x}\)

\(y = 1\frac{1}{6}\) when \(x = 8\)

Find the value of \(y\) when \(x = 64\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Setting up the proportionality equation

What are we being asked to find?

We need to find the specific value of \(y\) for a new \(x\). To do this, we first need to build the exact equation that links \(y\) and \(x\).

Why we do this:

“Directly proportional” means that \(y\) is equal to some constant multiplier (we call it \(k\)) times the other expression. We write this as an equation with \(k\) to help us find the multiplier.

Working:

\[ y = k\sqrt[3]{x} \]

(M1) for writing the correct proportionality equation.

Step 2: Finding the constant \(k\)

Why we do this:

We are given a pair of values (\(x=8, y=1\frac{1}{6}\)) that we know work together. By substituting these into our equation, we can calculate the secret multiplier \(k\). It’s easier to work with improper fractions, so let’s convert \(1\frac{1}{6}\) into \(\frac{7}{6}\).

Working:

Substitute \(x = 8\) and \(y = \frac{7}{6}\):

\[ \frac{7}{6} = k \times \sqrt[3]{8} \]

The cube root of \(8\) is \(2\) (since \(2 \times 2 \times 2 = 8\)):

\[ \frac{7}{6} = k \times 2 \]

Divide both sides by \(2\) to isolate \(k\):

\[ k = \frac{7}{6} \div 2 = \frac{7}{12} \]

(M1) for correctly substituting to find \(k\).

So our full formula is:

\[ y = \frac{7}{12}\sqrt[3]{x} \]
Step 3: Calculating \(y\) when \(x = 64\)

Why we do this:

Now that we have our complete formula, we can just plug in the new \(x\) value to find the required \(y\).

Working:

Substitute \(x = 64\) into the formula:

\[ y = \frac{7}{12} \times \sqrt[3]{64} \]

The cube root of \(64\) is \(4\) (since \(4 \times 4 \times 4 = 64\)):

\[ y = \frac{7}{12} \times 4 \] \[ y = \frac{28}{12} \]

Simplify the fraction by dividing top and bottom by \(4\):

\[ y = \frac{7}{3} \quad \text{(or } 2\frac{1}{3}\text{)} \]

(A1) for the correct final answer.

Final Answer:

\(\frac{7}{3}\)

Total: 3 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 17 (2 marks)

\(n\) is an integer.

Prove algebraically that the sum of \(\frac{1}{2}n(n + 1)\) and \(\frac{1}{2}(n + 1)(n + 2)\) is always a square number.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Adding the two expressions

What are we being asked to do?

We need to add (“sum”) these two algebraic expressions together and simplify them. The final result should look like something squared (like \(x^2\) or \((something)^2\)).

Why we do this:

We can’t prove it’s a square number while it’s in two separate messy pieces. We need to combine them into one neat expression.

Working:

Write out the sum:

\[ \frac{1}{2}n(n + 1) + \frac{1}{2}(n + 1)(n + 2) \]
Step 2: Factorising the expression

Why we do this:

Notice that both terms share a common factor: they both have a \(\frac{1}{2}\) and an \((n + 1)\). We can pull this common factor out to the front. (Alternatively, you could expand all the brackets, but factorising is quicker and less prone to errors!)

Working:

Factor out \(\frac{1}{2}(n + 1)\):

\[ \frac{1}{2}(n + 1) \Big[ n + (n + 2) \Big] \]

(M1) for attempting to factorise (or expanding all terms correctly).

Now simplify the expression inside the square brackets:

\[ \frac{1}{2}(n + 1) \Big[ 2n + 2 \Big] \]

Notice that \(2n + 2\) can also be factorised by taking out a \(2\):

\[ \frac{1}{2}(n + 1) \Big[ 2(n + 1) \Big] \]
Step 3: Completing the proof

Why we do this:

We multiply the pieces together to show the final form, then explain why that form proves it’s a square number.

Working:

Multiply the \(\frac{1}{2}\) by the \(2\):

\[ \frac{1}{2} \times 2 \times (n + 1) \times (n + 1) \] \[ 1 \times (n + 1)^2 \] \[ (n + 1)^2 \]

What this tells us:

Since the question states \(n\) is an integer (a whole number), \(n + 1\) must also be an integer. When you square an integer, the result is a square number. We have proven it!

(C1) for completing the proof with reference to \((n+1)^2\).

Final Answer:

The sum simplifies to \((n + 1)^2\). Since \(n\) is an integer, \(n + 1\) is an integer. An integer squared is a square number, thus the statement is proven.

Total: 2 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 18 (2 marks)

Enlarge shape P by scale factor \(-\frac{1}{2}\) with centre of enlargement \((0,0)\).

Label your image Q.

x y O -8 -6 -4 -2 2 4 6 8 -8 -6 -4 -2 2 4 6 8 P

Worked Solution

Step 1: Understanding Negative Scale Factors

What are we doing?

We need to enlarge shape P, but the scale factor is \(-\frac{1}{2}\). A negative scale factor does two things:

  • The “\(\frac{1}{2}\)” part means the new shape will be exactly half the size of the original.
  • The “negative” part means the shape is projected through the centre of enlargement (the origin) to the opposite side of the grid, turning it upside down.
Step 2: Calculating the new coordinates

Why we do this:

To safely draw the new shape, we take the coordinates of the corners of shape P, and multiply both the \(x\) and \(y\) values by our scale factor \(-\frac{1}{2}\).

Working:

Vertices of original Shape P:

  • Bottom-left: \((2, 3)\)
  • Bottom-right: \((4, 3)\)
  • Top-left: \((2, 7)\)

Multiply each number by \(-\frac{1}{2}\) to get the vertices of new Shape Q:

  • \((2 \times -\frac{1}{2}, 3 \times -\frac{1}{2}) \rightarrow \mathbf{(-1, -1.5)}\)
  • \((4 \times -\frac{1}{2}, 3 \times -\frac{1}{2}) \rightarrow \mathbf{(-2, -1.5)}\)
  • \((2 \times -\frac{1}{2}, 7 \times -\frac{1}{2}) \rightarrow \mathbf{(-1, -3.5)}\)
Step 3: Plotting the new shape

Why we do this:

We plot these three new points on the grid and join them up. Because the scale factor was negative, notice how the shape is now inverted and on the opposite side of the origin \((0,0)\).

Working:

See the blue triangle Q in the diagram below.

x y O -8-448 -8-448 P Q

(B2) for correct enlargement drawn in the correct position.

Final Answer:

Shape Q plotted at coordinates \((-1, -1.5)\), \((-2, -1.5)\), and \((-1, -3.5)\) as shown in the diagram.

Total: 2 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 19 (4 marks)

x y O L M A B C D E

\(ABCD\) is a rectangle.

\(A, E\) and \(B\) are points on the straight line \(L\) with equation \(x + 2y = 12\)

\(A\) and \(D\) are points on the straight line \(M\).

\(AE = EB\)

Find an equation for \(M\).

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding coordinates for points E and B

What are we looking for?

We need the equation of line \(M\). To get it, we need a point it passes through (like \(A\)) and its gradient. Let’s start by using line \(L\)’s equation to find the exact coordinates of \(E\) and \(B\).

Why we do this:

Looking at the diagram, \(E\) crosses the y-axis, meaning its x-coordinate is \(0\). Point \(B\) crosses the x-axis, meaning its y-coordinate is \(0\). We can substitute these into \(x + 2y = 12\).

Working:

For point E (on y-axis, so \(x = 0\)):

\[ 0 + 2y = 12 \Rightarrow y = 6 \]

So, point \(E\) is at \((0, 6)\).

For point B (on x-axis, so \(y = 0\)):

\[ x + 2(0) = 12 \Rightarrow x = 12 \]

So, point \(B\) is at \((12, 0)\).

(P1) for starting the process by finding positions of B and E.

Step 2: Finding the coordinates of A

Why we do this:

We are told \(AE = EB\). This means point \(E\) is exactly halfway between \(A\) and \(B\) (it’s the midpoint). We can use the midpoint logic backwards to find \(A\).

Working:

To get from \(B(12, 0)\) to \(E(0, 6)\):

  • x changes by \(-12\)
  • y changes by \(+6\)

To get from \(E\) to \(A\), we must apply that exact same movement again (since \(E\) is the midpoint):

  • x for A: \(0 – 12 = -12\)
  • y for A: \(6 + 6 = 12\)

So, point \(A\) is at \((-12, 12)\).

Step 3: Finding the gradient of Line M

Why we do this:

Because \(ABCD\) is a rectangle, the corners are \(90^\circ\) right angles. This means line \(M\) (passing through AD) is exactly perpendicular to line \(L\) (passing through AB). If we know the gradient of \(L\), we can find the perpendicular gradient for \(M\).

Working:

First, find the gradient of \(L\) by rearranging its equation into \(y = mx + c\):

\[ 2y = -x + 12 \] \[ y = -0.5x + 6 \]

Gradient of \(L\) is \(-\frac{1}{2}\).

Perpendicular gradients multiply to \(-1\) (you flip the fraction and change the sign):

Gradient of \(M = 2\).

(P1) for complete process to find position of A, OR using \(-\frac{1}{m}\) to find the gradient of M.

Step 4: Writing the final equation for Line M

Why we do this:

We now have everything we need for line \(M\): its gradient (\(m = 2\)) and a point it passes through (\(A(-12, 12)\)). We use the formula \(y = mx + c\) to find the full equation.

Working:

\[ y = 2x + c \]

Substitute the coordinates of \(A(-12, 12)\) into the equation:

\[ 12 = 2(-12) + c \] \[ 12 = -24 + c \]

Add \(24\) to both sides:

\[ c = 36 \]

(P1) for a complete process to find the equation of M.

Final Answer:

\(y = 2x + 36\)

(A1) for the correct final equation.

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 20 (4 marks)

The table shows some values of \(x\) and \(y\) that satisfy the equation \(y = a \cos x^\circ + b\)

x \(0\) \(30\) \(60\) \(90\) \(120\) \(150\) \(180\)
y \(3\) \(1 + \sqrt{3}\) \(2\) \(1\) \(0\) \(1 – \sqrt{3}\) \(-1\)

Find the value of \(y\) when \(x = 45\)

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding the value of \(b\)

What are we being asked to do?

We need to find \(y\) at \(x=45^\circ\). But right now, our equation \(y = a \cos x^\circ + b\) has two unknown constants, \(a\) and \(b\). We must find these first using the table.

Why we do this:

We look for an \(x\) value in the table where \(\cos x\) is \(0\). We know that \(\cos 90^\circ = 0\). If we plug \(x=90\) into our equation, the ‘\(a\)’ will multiply by \(0\) and vanish, letting us find \(b\) easily.

Working:

From the table, when \(x = 90^\circ\), \(y = 1\).

\[ y = a \cos(90^\circ) + b \] \[ 1 = a(0) + b \] \[ 1 = b \]

(P1) for forming equations or stating one correct value (\(b=1\)).

Step 2: Finding the value of \(a\)

Why we do this:

Now we know the equation is \(y = a \cos x^\circ + 1\). To find \(a\), we just need to plug in another pair of values from the table. Using \(x = 0\) is best because \(\cos 0^\circ = 1\).

Working:

From the table, when \(x = 0^\circ\), \(y = 3\).

\[ y = a \cos(0^\circ) + 1 \] \[ 3 = a(1) + 1 \] \[ 3 = a + 1 \] \[ a = 2 \]

(P1) for a complete process to reach \(a=2\) and \(b=1\).

Step 3: Calculating \(y\) at \(x = 45^\circ\)

Why we do this:

Now we have our complete equation: \(y = 2 \cos x^\circ + 1\). We simply substitute \(x = 45\) into it. We must know our exact trigonometric values for this (Non-Calculator paper).

Working:

Recall that \(\cos 45^\circ = \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2}\) (which is the same as \(\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\)).

(B1) for stating the correct exact value for \(\cos 45^\circ\).

Substitute this into our completed equation:

\[ y = 2 \left( \frac{\sqrt{2}}{2} \right) + 1 \]

The \(2\) at the front and the \(2\) on the bottom cancel out:

\[ y = \sqrt{2} + 1 \]

What this tells us:

We successfully worked out the full formula from the data points, and applied our exact trig knowledge to find the specific missing value.

Final Answer:

\(1 + \sqrt{2}\)

(A1) for \(1 + \sqrt{2}\) (or equivalent).

Total: 4 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 21 (3 marks)

Show that \(\frac{6 – \sqrt{8}}{\sqrt{2} – 1}\) can be written in the form \(a + b\sqrt{2}\) where \(a\) and \(b\) are integers.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Rationalising the denominator

What are we being asked to do?

We need to remove the square root from the bottom of the fraction. This process is called “rationalising the denominator”.

Why we do this:

To eliminate a surd like \(\sqrt{2} – 1\) from the denominator, we multiply the top and the bottom of the fraction by its “conjugate”. The conjugate is exactly the same, but with the sign in the middle flipped. So, we multiply by \(\sqrt{2} + 1\).

Working:

\[ \frac{6 – \sqrt{8}}{\sqrt{2} – 1} \times \frac{\sqrt{2} + 1}{\sqrt{2} + 1} \]

(M1) for correct first step: multiplying numerator and denominator by \(\sqrt{2} + 1\).

Step 2: Expanding the brackets

Why we do this:

We must carefully expand the double brackets on both the top and the bottom, just like we would with algebraic expressions like \((x-y)(x+y)\).

Working:

Denominator (bottom):

\[ (\sqrt{2} – 1)(\sqrt{2} + 1) = \sqrt{2}\sqrt{2} + \sqrt{2} – \sqrt{2} – 1 = 2 – 1 = 1 \]

Because the denominator becomes \(1\), we only need to worry about the numerator now!

Numerator (top):

\[ (6 – \sqrt{8})(\sqrt{2} + 1) \] \[ = 6\sqrt{2} + 6 – \sqrt{8}\sqrt{2} – \sqrt{8} \]

(M1) for expansion of numerator with at least 3 out of exactly 4 terms correct.

Step 3: Simplifying the surds

Why we do this:

We need to collect like terms and simplify any surds that can be broken down to match the required format \(a + b\sqrt{2}\).

Working:

Let’s simplify the pieces:

  • \(\sqrt{8}\sqrt{2} = \sqrt{16} = 4\)
  • \(\sqrt{8} = \sqrt{4 \times 2} = 2\sqrt{2}\)

Substitute these back into our expanded numerator:

\[ 6\sqrt{2} + 6 – 4 – 2\sqrt{2} \]

Collect the normal numbers (\(6 – 4\)) and the \(\sqrt{2}\) terms (\(6\sqrt{2} – 2\sqrt{2}\)):

\[ 2 + 4\sqrt{2} \]

What this tells us:

We have successfully written the expression in the required format. Here, \(a = 2\) and \(b = 4\).

Final Answer:

\(2 + 4\sqrt{2}\)

(A1) for \(2 + 4\sqrt{2}\) or equivalent (or stating \(a=2\) and \(b=4\)).

Total: 3 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 22 (5 marks)

The two triangles in the diagram are similar.

A B C D E x cm 8 cm 12 cm 3 cm

There are two possible values of \(x\).

Work out each of these values.

State any assumptions you make in your working.

Worked Solution

Step 1: Understanding the diagram and similarity

What are we being asked to find?

We need to find the length \(CB\) (which is \(x\)). We are told the large triangle \(CDA\) is similar to the smaller internal triangle \(BEA\). However, we are not told how they align. This is why there are two possible answers—there are two ways the triangles can be similar.

Let’s map out the total lengths of the large triangle’s sides first:

  • Side \(AC = x + 8\)
  • Side \(AD = 12 + 3 = 15\)
Step 2: Case 1 – Assuming the base lines are parallel

Why we do this:

Assumption 1: We assume that line \(BE\) is parallel to line \(CD\). This means the triangles are perfectly aligned (\(\angle ABE = \angle ACD\) and \(\angle AEB = \angle ADC\)).

Working:

In this case, the side \(AB\) corresponds to the side \(AC\), and the side \(AE\) corresponds to the side \(AD\).

Let’s find the scale factor from the small triangle to the large triangle using the base sides we know completely:

\[ \text{Scale Factor} = \frac{AD}{AE} = \frac{15}{12} = \frac{5}{4} = 1.25 \]

(P1) for correctly identifying scale factor or ratio of corresponding sides.

Now apply this to the other sides: \(AC = AB \times \text{Scale Factor}\)

\[ (x + 8) = 8 \times \frac{15}{12} \] \[ x + 8 = 10 \] \[ x = 2 \]

(A1) for \(x = 2\).

Step 3: Case 2 – Assuming the triangle is “flipped”

Why we do this:

Assumption 2: We assume that the small triangle is inverted relative to the large one. This means \(\angle ABE = \angle ADC\) and \(\angle AEB = \angle ACD\).

Working:

In this flipped alignment, side \(AB\) corresponds to side \(AD\), and side \(AE\) corresponds to side \(AC\).

Let’s find the new scale factor using the known corresponding sides \(AD\) and \(AB\):

\[ \text{Scale Factor} = \frac{AD}{AB} = \frac{15}{8} = 1.875 \]

Now apply this to the other corresponding pair: \(AC = AE \times \text{Scale Factor}\)

\[ (x + 8) = 12 \times \frac{15}{8} \]

(P1) for a complete method to find the other value for \(x\).

Let’s simplify that multiplication. \(12 \div 4 = 3\), and \(8 \div 4 = 2\):

\[ x + 8 = 3 \times \frac{15}{2} \] \[ x + 8 = \frac{45}{2} \] \[ x + 8 = 22.5 \]

Subtract \(8\) from both sides:

\[ x = 14.5 \]

(A1) for \(x = 14.5\).

Final Answer:

\(x = 2\) or \(x = 14.5\)

Assumptions:
1. Triangle \(ABE\) is similar to Triangle \(ACD\) (line \(BE\) is parallel to \(CD\)).
2. Triangle \(ABE\) is similar to Triangle \(ADC\) (the small triangle is ‘flipped’ inside the large one).

(C1) for describing both assumptions for similarity.

Total: 5 marks

↑ Back to Top

Question 23 (5 marks)

Here is a rectangle and a right-angled triangle.

3x − 2 x − 1 2x x

All measurements are in centimetres.

The area of the rectangle is greater than the area of the triangle.

Find the set of possible values of \(x\).

Worked Solution

Step 1: Finding expressions for the areas

What are we doing?

We are told about the relationship between their areas. So, first, we must write down algebraic expressions for the area of both shapes.

Working:

Area of Rectangle = \(\text{width} \times \text{height}\)

\[ \text{Rectangle Area} = (3x – 2)(x – 1) \]

Area of Triangle = \(\frac{1}{2} \times \text{base} \times \text{height}\)

\[ \text{Triangle Area} = \frac{1}{2} \times x \times 2x = \frac{1}{2}(2x^2) = x^2 \]

(P1) for the process to derive algebraic expressions for the area of both shapes.

Step 2: Setting up and simplifying the inequality

Why we do this:

The question states: “Area of rectangle > Area of triangle”. We insert our expressions into this inequality, expand the brackets, and rearrange it so that it is greater than zero. This turns it into a standard quadratic inequality that we can solve.

Working:

\[ (3x – 2)(x – 1) > x^2 \]

Expand the double brackets (FOIL):

\[ 3x^2 – 3x – 2x + 2 > x^2 \] \[ 3x^2 – 5x + 2 > x^2 \]

Subtract \(x^2\) from both sides to get zero on the right:

\[ 2x^2 – 5x + 2 > 0 \]

(M1) for method to rearrange inequality to the form \(ax^2 + bx + c > 0\).

Step 3: Solving the quadratic inequality

Why we do this:

To solve \(2x^2 – 5x + 2 > 0\), we first find the “critical values” by pretending it’s an “equals” sign and factorising it. These critical values tell us where the quadratic curve crosses the x-axis.

Working:

Factorise \(2x^2 – 5x + 2 = 0\):

We need two numbers that multiply to \(2 \times 2 = 4\) and add to \(-5\). These are \(-4\) and \(-1\).

\[ 2x^2 – 4x – x + 2 = 0 \] \[ 2x(x – 2) – 1(x – 2) = 0 \] \[ (2x – 1)(x – 2) = 0 \]

(M1) for a correct method to solve the quadratic equation.

So our critical values are:

\[ x = \frac{1}{2} \quad \text{and} \quad x = 2 \]

(M1) for establishing the critical values \(\frac{1}{2}\) and \(2\).

Step 4: Finding the valid set of values

Why we do this:

A positive \(x^2\) quadratic makes a U-shape. It is greater than zero (\(>0\)) on the outside of the critical values. So mathematically, \(x < \frac{1}{2}\) or \(x > 2\).

However, this is a real-world geometry problem. Lengths cannot be negative or zero. Look at the rectangle’s height: \(x – 1\). If \(x\) was less than \(\frac{1}{2}\) (for example, \(0\)), the height would be \(0 – 1 = -1\text{ cm}\). This is impossible! Therefore, \(x\) must be large enough to make all sides positive.

Working:

Mathematical regions: \(x < 0.5\) or \(x > 2\).

For sides to exist, \(x – 1 > 0 \Rightarrow x > 1\).

Because \(x\) must be greater than \(1\), we must reject the entire \(x < 0.5\) region.

The only valid mathematical region remaining is \(x > 2\).

What this tells us:

For the rectangle’s area to be strictly greater than the triangle’s area, while ensuring the physical shapes can actually exist, \(x\) must be any value greater than \(2\).

Final Answer:

\(x > 2\)

(A1) for identifying the correct single inequality region.

Total: 5 marks

↑ Back to Top